Ontario Real Estate Agents Directory
Menu

McLay Real Estate

Updated 2026-10-09 · 14,457 reviewed · 200 listed · Scored from 450 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.9(450) 93 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Luxury Home SpecialistsNew Construction & Pre-ConstructionRental & Leasing AgentsInvestment Property AgentsResidential Home Sales
McLay Real Estate
Location
Old Toronto, Toronto
Services
Luxury Home Specialists, New Construction & Pre-Construction, Rental & Leasing Agents
Reviews
450
Ranking
#33 in Luxury Home Specialists
Best for
People wanting responsive agents who explain each step, especially first-time buyers and renters

Business data from Google Business Profile, checked 2026-10-09.

What do customers say?

Reviewers describe agents who answer messages fast and stay patient through long searches. Many say the team explains each step, so they feel informed when buying or renting. Several first-time buyers say they felt well supported from the first viewing to closing.

Reviewers name a range of agents, from Tyler and Paul to Jenna, Sue, Noel, Giancarlo, Brittany, Andrew, Jordan, Patrick and Jelani. Praise centres on rental searches, condo purchases and out-of-town clients. One reviewer who moved from another province says the team found and secured an apartment quickly.

Praised for
  • responsive by phone and messages
  • patient with questions and searches
  • explains each step clearly
  • helpful for first-time buyers and renters
  • works well with lenders and lawyers
responsiveprofessionalknowledgeablepatientgreat-communicationhelpful-first-time-buyersfirst-time-buyersnewcomersinvestors
Best for: People wanting responsive agents who explain each step, especially first-time buyers and renters

What stands out?

  • fast replies to messages and calls
  • patient guidance for first-time buyers
  • handles remote viewings and neighbourhood tours
  • steady support through leasing and purchases

Worth knowing

  • Google rating 4.9 across 450 reviews, with 98% five-star
  • Named agents in reviews include Tyler, Paul DeMaria, Jenna Araneta, Sue McLay, Noel, Giancarlo, Brittany, Andrew, Jordan Medieros, Patrick and Jelani Bartlett
  • Reviewers mention remote FaceTime viewings and measurements taken after signing
  • Reviewer mentions a mortgage broker praising the team's coordination with lawyers and lenders
  • Reviewers mention successful condo purchases, rentals and first home purchases

How it compares

  • Rated 4.9 against a 4.94 average across the 198 residential home sales businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 97% of the businesses in this directory.

How the score was calculated

Scoring Method
Star rating 93
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 81
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
442
4
0
3
0
2
1
1
7

Frequently asked questions

Do the agents respond quickly?
Many reviewers say their agent answered calls and messages quickly, including one client living 10 hours away.
Do they help people who are moving to Toronto from elsewhere?
Yes. One reviewer who moved from another province says the agent found and secured an apartment for them.

Similar real estate agents nearby

Kyle Aguilera Pacheco
85

Kyle Aguilera Pacheco

5.0(15)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers describe a responsive agent who stays available from the first search through signing. Many say he listens closely to what clients need and screens properties so they do not waste time on poor fits. Several mention he handled rentals and purchases, and that he stayed calm and patient with buyers.

Investment Property AgentsLuxury Home SpecialistsResidential Home Sales
Properly Toronto
85 low data

Properly Toronto

4.9(129)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Most reviewers describe prompt replies and clear explanations from their agents. Several say agents kept them informed at every step. One 1-star review from three years ago describes a home sale that did not go as hoped.

Luxury Home SpecialistsNew Construction & Pre-ConstructionRental & Leasing Agents
Michael Campea, Toronto Real Estate Broker
87

Michael Campea, Toronto Real Estate Broker

5.0(29)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers describe Michael as responsive, patient, and easy to reach. Many say he never pressured them, even when they viewed several homes in one day. Clients often mention he kept them informed about the market and each step. Clients also talk about the extra help he gives beyond listings. One reviewer says he curated listings daily and went to see homes when they could not attend. Another says he connected them with trusted agents in another city and country. Several praise his honesty and the way he explains things clearly.

Residential Home SalesLuxury Home SpecialistsRental & Leasing Agents

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-10-09